Adapted CTET December 2024 Set E question 112: A educator of class VI develops the following task for a speaking activity. Speak five sentences about desert and its climatic conditions. Is it a good task or not a good task? Select from option your response and reason for the same.

1. It is a good task because the learners may have studied about desert in their geography class and will have inputs to speak.
2. It is a good task because it makes the learner to talk about something i.e the desert.
3. It is not a good task because some of the learners may not know about desert.
4. It is not a good task because it lacks context as there is no input for speaking about desert and its conditions.